Lawsuit: Verizon Slowed Firefighters’ Internet During Wildfire

Lawsuit: Verizon Slowed Firefighters’ Internet During Wildfire

Lawsuit: Verizon Slowed Firefighters’ Internet During Wildfire

The brief asserts that when the FCC struck down net neutrality rules, it failed to consider the public's need to access a free and open internet for government services.

When Santa Clara Fire Department reached out to Verizon to fix the problem, they were told that the department needed to switch to a higher data plan, which was more than twice the cost they were paying for the original plan. The suit claims that once net neutrality was taken off the books, the Fire Department's service was throttled not only during times of network congestion, but all of the time.

Ars Technica earlier reported on the allegations against Verizon by fire department in Santa Clara, Califorina.

Buss eventually suggested a $99 plan that would charge the fire department $8 per gigabyte after 20GB had been used.

Verizon told The Washington Post in a statement Wednesday that it made a customer support mistake with the fire department and should have lifted the data speed restrictions during the emergency.

The company went on to say it should have lifted restrictions in the emergency situation.

ConocoPhillips, Venezuela’s PDVSA reach $2 bln settlement
The remainder is to be paid quarterly over a period of 4-1/2 years, Conoco said in a statement. Conoco's shares were up 1.5 percent at $70.83 in afternoon trading.

The Santa Clara County fire department accuses the internet service provider of slowing down service on its devices despite knowledge that the slowdown was making it hard for firefighters to coordinate resources as they fought the blaze. "This situation has nothing to do with net neutrality or the current proceeding in court", she said.

In the declaration, Bowden said internet systems are important "in providing fire and emergency response, particularly for events like large fires which require rapid deployment and organization" of personnel, resources and equipment.

"In the midst of our response to the Mendocino Complex Fire, County Fire discovered the data connection for OES 5262 was being throttled by Verizon, and data rates had been reduced to 1/200, or less, than the previous speeds". The vehicle is a "command and control resource" that helps direct traffic during big fires and other emergencies, coordinating with other agencies, he added.

Slowing down data speeds after a customer reaches its monthly data limit is a common practice among internet service providers and cellular carriers that's known as throttling.

LACK OF OVERSIGHT. Verizon may not have violated the net neutrality rule against throttling (after all, it slowed down all of the SCCFD's activity, not just activity geared toward one site), but the repeal might still play a role in this situation. "That is exactly what the Trump Administration's repeal of Net Neutrality allows and encourages". The throttling in Mendocino wasn't the first such incident, and Bowden said that Verizon will likely keep restricting data during emergencies to force public agencies into more expensive plans. "Under this plan, users get an unlimited amount of data but speeds are reduced when they exceed their allotment until the next billing cycle", Verizon's statement reads. Instead the throttling and extra cost for the Santa Clara Fire Department was "a mistake in how we communicated with our customer about the terms of its plan".

Recommended News

  • Ariana Grande will take Pete Davidson's surname

    Ariana Grande will take Pete Davidson's surname

    "We met on SNL, like, two, three years ago", she said of Davidson . "I'm just grateful, enjoying every minute because life is too short".
    Eden Hazard's future rests on Chelsea qualifying for Champions League

    Eden Hazard's future rests on Chelsea qualifying for Champions League

    Moreover, the West London giants also lack the necessary depth in their attacking department for them to cope without Hazard. This means that Real Madrid still has eight odd days in hand to decide if they're interested.
    Two new cases of West Nile Virus in Mississippi

    Two new cases of West Nile Virus in Mississippi

    The health department urged residents of Tooele County to take precautions to prevent mosquito bites and the spread of the virus. It could take up to 14 days for symptoms to occur and those over 60 years old are at the highest risk.
  • Workers with open office seating are less stressed

    Workers with open office seating are less stressed

    The data also showed those working in open plan offices took around 1,000 more steps a day than those with their own office. Older office workers were more likely to have higher stress levels.
    Idris Elba Addresses James Bond Rumors During

    Idris Elba Addresses James Bond Rumors During "Yardie" Premiere

    Asked by Good Morning Britain if he would prefer his Martini shaken or stirred, he replied: "Stir-fried, actually". Daniel Craig has played James Bond for four films now, Casino Royale , Quantum of Solace , Skyfall , and Spectre .

    Using Electronic Cigarettes Can Damage DNA

    The saliva of a small group of e-cigarette users contained increased levels of three DNA-damaging compounds, the researchers said. If cells are unable to fix the damage to allow the DNA to replicate normally, there is a chance that cancer will develop.
  • Trump assails Mueller following Times report

    Trump assails Mueller following Times report

    Trump reportedly tried to get Jeff Sessions involved in the Russian Federation investigation and contemplated firing Mueller. The paper said McGahn was motivated in part by fear that the president might set him up to be held responsible.
    Hurricane watch posted as Lane approaches

    Hurricane watch posted as Lane approaches

    Hawaii generally sees about one storm strong enough to earn a name pass within 60 miles of the islands every four years. Bands of heavy rain will dump as much as 20 inches moving northward across the state, according to the CPHC.
    Vikings Likely to Sign S George Iloka

    Vikings Likely to Sign S George Iloka

    According to Tom Pelissero of the NFL Network , the Vikings will bring in and likely sign safety George Iloka on Wednesday. Andrew Sendejo is now listed as the team's starting strong safety after making 13 starts for the team last season.
  • Jury Finds Paul Manafort Guilty In Federal Tax And Bank Fraud Trial

    Jury Finds Paul Manafort Guilty In Federal Tax And Bank Fraud Trial

    Cohen "decided that he was above the law, and for that he is going to pay a very, very serious price", Khuzami said. The jury deliberated for four days before announcing the verdict at the federal courthouse in Alexandria, Virginia .
    US Punishes Russian Firms For Violated N. Korea Sanctions

    US Punishes Russian Firms For Violated N. Korea Sanctions

    Russian officials said the whole sanctions effort was done under "false pretense", and that Russia would soon offer a retaliation against the United States over the sanctions.
    'Crazy Rich Asians' rules at the box office

    'Crazy Rich Asians' rules at the box office

    Upon meeting his parents, she quickly finds out his family is one of the richest (and most judgmental!) in Singapore. Prior to that, "I Feel Pretty" - with Amy Schumer, Michelle Williams, Emily Ratajkowski - bowed with $16 million.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.