
Google chief executive Sundar Pichai
That's the recommendation of a top legal advisor to the EU's Court of Justice.
Szpunar advised the court to rule in Google's favor in this case, though he said he "does not rule out the possibility that, in certain situations, a search engine operator may be required to take de-referencing actions at the worldwide level".
The French data watchdog had gone to the European Court of Justice to establish whether it could force companies such as Google to de-list search results across the world under the right to be forgotten (RTBF) law. Google and other technology advocates rebutted that allowing the law's scope to expand globally would allow repressive regimes to essentially erase all dissenting online content about them around the world.
France's CNIL data protection authority said it noted the opinion and restated its view that the right to privacy should apply regardless of the geographical origin of the person doing an internet search.
European Court of Justice judges typically follow the advice of the advocate general, usually within two to four months, although they are not bound to do so.
They should accede, as a matter of course, to de-referencing requests, said Szpunar.
The U.S. company has been asked to delete links to 2.9 million websites, after the European Union court effectively put the search engine in charge of deciding what requests to accept.
If it was allowed, "the European Union authorities would not be able to define and determine a right to receive information, let alone balance it against the other fundamental rights to data protection and to privacy", a summary (PDF) of the decision said.
Google announces big plans for voice assistant at CES 2019
In order to enable the so-called " Pixel lockscreen Assistant" feature, you'll have to opt-in through the phone's settings. By saying, "Hey Google, check in to my flight", the assistant will walk through the steps of checking in.
The advocate general on Thursday in that case said that for requests concerning sensitive data, search engine operators "must weigh up, on the one hand, the right to respect for private life" and data protection rights, and "on the other hand, the right of the public to access the information concerned" and the freedom of expression.
The Alphabet Inc. unit now removes such links EU-wide and since 2016 it also restricts access to such information on non-EU Google sites when accessed from the EU country where the person concerned by the information is located - referred to as geo-blocking.
"European data regulators should not be able to determine the search results that internet users around the world get to see".
"We hope that the CJEU will follow Szpunar's opinion when it issues its judgment in this case later this year", said Thomas Hughes, the executive director of anti-censorship organization Article 19.
This is made even more hard to weigh up as the public interest in accessing information will vary from one non-EU country to another, and global delisting would prevent people in those states from accessing information.
This case involves the CNIL's refusal to order the removal of links found in searches using individuals' names.
The Right To Be Forgotten applies to a search result that is deemed "inadequate, irrelevant or no longer relevant, or excessive" and - as of 10 January 2019 - Google had delisted 1.1 million URLs, approving about 44 per cent of requests.
Recommended News
-
Samsung Reveals 219-Inch TV Called 'The Wall'
The annual Consumer Electronics Show - or CES - is the world's most significant preview into technology coming up for the masses. Anyone who brags about having a 65 inch TV needs to sit down and be humble after Samsung's announcement of "The Wall".Bengals targeting Rams' Taylor as next head coach
In Cleveland, Freddie Kitchens has been promoted to head coach after taking over the offense as an interim offensive coordinator. Taylor also represents a more overarching trend in the National Football League : hiring young, offensive-minded head coaches.Virat Kohli slams India star Hardik Pandya for 'inappropriate comments'
He said, "We as the Indian cricket team and responsible cricketers don't align with those views, those were individual opinions". On the show, Pandya had boasted about hooking up with multiple women and being open about it with his parents. -
Andrew Putnam shoots 62 to lead Sony Open after first round
Putnam, 29, has been a consistent performer in his two-plus seasons on the PGA Tour, without making too many headlines. Kapalua was built on the side of a mountain, with enormous greens and large undulations.Netflix Sued In ‘Black Mirror: Bandersnatch’ ‘Choose Your Own Adventure’ Lawsuit
In fact, just a couple of weeks after its debut, Bandersnatch is already at the center of a lawsuit directed at Netflix . The franchise was extremely popular during the 1980s, growing to 184 books with more than 250 million copies printed.Study finds many medical marijuana users drive while high
They were recruited at three different medical cannabis certification centers in MI . The researchers asked about respondents' driving habits for the past six months. -
China Trade Talks Restart Ahead of March Deadline
Last year, the United States imposed tariff hikes of up to 25 per cent on Dollars 250 billion of Chinese goods. Companies in both countries just want to see a deal get done. -China Business Council said in a statement.Sheriff: Helicopter blade kills man at Brooksville airport Yesterday
A person was decapitated by a helicopter in an accident at a Florida airport on Thursday afternoon, reports said. Local TV stations showed one of the helicopter's main rotors badly splintered after the impact.Leeds United accused of 'spying' on rivals Derby County during training
Derby County have confirmed police found a member of staff at Leeds United "acting suspiciously" outside their training ground. Derby are now in sixth position, while Leeds are league leaders just eight points ahead. -
Cesc Fabregas completes switch to Thierry Henry's AS Monaco
The Spanish midfielder joins the Ligue 1 side for a fee believed to be between eight and ten million euros. The Spaniard has now completed the move to Monaco , signing a three-and-a-half year deal.Mike Priefer departs as Vikings' special teams coordinator, will join Browns
That announcement is coming, eventually, and Kitchens has been working since Wednesday as the head coach. As of Friday afternoon, the Browns still had not officially announced Freddie Kitchens as head coach.Chelsea boss Sarri hits back at Bayern after Hudson-Odoi comments
I am very happy with the player, he is improving a lot. "At the moment, for his mental condition, he's not able to play". Willian was on Thursday linked with Barcelona, but Sarri ruled out the prospect of the Brazilian departing this month.