Court rules Sandy Hook lawsuit against Remington can proceed

Connecticut Supreme Court gives families in Sandy Hook case new hope in their suit against gun maker

Connecticut Supreme Court gives families in Sandy Hook case new hope in their suit against gun maker

Since Sandy Hook and subsequent school shootings, most federal efforts at gun control or gun rights expansion have faded and the bulk of firearms legislation has been in state legislatures across the country.

A divided Connecticut Supreme Court ruled Thursday that gun manufacturer Remington can be sued for alleged wrongful marketing of its Bushmaster AR-15 rifle, which was used in the mass murder of children and teachers at Newtown's Sandy Hook Elementary School in 2012.

Lanza used a Bushmaster XM15-E2S rifle during the shooting, which the plaintiffs argue is a similar weapon to the AR-15.

On Thursday, the justices ruled that while the lower court was correct in dismissing numerous plaintiffs' claims in the wrongful death lawsuit, the plaintiffs should be allowed to proceed with arguments on whether Remington's marketing of the weapon violated state trade practices.

In a 4-3 opinion, the court narrowly ruled that families of victims of the Newtown school shooting can challenge whether Remington violated trade practices in how it marketed the AR-15-style rifle used in the shooting. "Today's decision is a critical step toward achieving that goal", said Josh Koskoff, one of the attorneys for the families, in a statement.

The 2005 Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act, or PLCAA, has provided the USA firearms industry an nearly impenetrable defense against lawsuits by victims of mass shootings and gun violence, broadly shielding Remington and others such as American Outdoor Brands Corp, Sturm Ruger & Co and Vista Outdoor Inc from liability. The case was then moved up to the state's highest court, and the decision to move forward was issued Thursday.

The families had tried to advance the case on a relatively novel argument in gun litigation based on the legal doctrine of negligent entrustment, an argument historically used when someone lends a auto to a high-risk driver who then causes an accident.

Pizza Pizza is offering $3.14 pizzas March 14 only
Mountain Mike's is offering $5 off any "mountain-sized" pizza (that's a really big pizza) and $3 off any large-sized pizza. Marie Callender's: Get a free slice of pie at Marie Callender's with the purchase of an adult entree.

The legal theory that the court rejected, which aimed to take advantage of another exception to the PLCAA's protection, was potentially much more threatening to the gun industry.

Remington has denied wrongdoing and previously insisted it can't be sued under the federal law.

The groundbreaking decision overturned a lower-court ruling barring the lawsuit, which was brought by the estates of nine victims killed by Adam Lanza, who was armed with the high-powered rifle during his assault on the school.

AR-15 rifles are displayed for sale at the Guntoberfest gun show in Oaks, Pa., Oct. 6, 2017.

At the heart of the argument was the extent of a federal law shielding firearm manufacturers from liability when illegal activity is conducted with their products.

Because this decision involves interpretation of a federal statute, the gunmaker will nearly certainly appeal it to the U.S. Supreme Court, and Remington could also prevail at a trial, so this is just a first step toward manufacturer liability.

Recommended News

  • K.J. Wright re-signing with Seahawks

    K.J. Wright re-signing with Seahawks

    Kendricks spent the first six years of his career with the Philadelphia Eagles with whom he won a Super Bowl in 2018. Early in his career, Iupati was one of the better guards in the National Football League and was solid through 2016.
    Floods kill 66 in Mozambique, 45 in Malawi

    Floods kill 66 in Mozambique, 45 in Malawi

    She spoke to reporters late Tuesday after a meeting of the Council of Ministers held in Maputo to discuss the deadly flooding. More than 168,000 hectares (415,000 acres) of crops were destroyed, the government spokeswoman added.
    Virgil van Dijk's Statistics From Bayern Munich Game Are Unbelievable

    Virgil van Dijk's Statistics From Bayern Munich Game Are Unbelievable

    Asked about the 27-year-old's performance, Klopp said: "It was brilliant". We didn't play our best but it's about getting a result.
  • USA  stock indexes end mostly higher, extending market’s gains

    USA stock indexes end mostly higher, extending market’s gains

    In electronic trading after the settlement, gold futures touched highs above $1,302, edging slightly higher after the Brexit vote. Shares in Southwest Airlines sank 2.12 percent while American Airlines lost 0.2 percent, United Continental gave up 0.8 percent.
    Captain Marvel will not release in Pakistan

    Captain Marvel will not release in Pakistan

    In any case, the trailer doesn't really give away much when it comes to how the Avengers actually plan to deal with the destruction Thanos wrought.
    Air Raid Sirens in Tel Aviv Over Apparent Gaza Rocket Attack

    Air Raid Sirens in Tel Aviv Over Apparent Gaza Rocket Attack

    The press service of the Israel Defence Forces confirmed that the sirens had sounded for the first time since summer 2014. The officials arrived in the Gaza Strip earlier in the day for talks with Hamas leaders on a possible truce with Israel.
  • Footage Released of Conor McGregor Stomping Out a Cell Phone

    Footage Released of Conor McGregor Stomping Out a Cell Phone

    He just ended his six-month suspension from the Nevada State Athletic Commission for his role in the UFC 229 post-fight brawl. Conor McGregor's phone smashing incident was caught on video and now that footage has surfaced online.
    Microsoft’s Xbox Live can soon work in any Android game

    Microsoft’s Xbox Live can soon work in any Android game

    Regardless of which features game developers pick, the features will be enabled through a single sign-in to a Microsoft account. They're releasing a new SDK for developers that will allow Xbox Live to be added to Android and iOS apps.
    Militao: new Real Madrid signing

    Militao: new Real Madrid signing

    Qualities that he has worn since his arrival last summer at Oporto, where he has shown a rapid adaptation to European football". Manchester United lose out to Real Madrid in the race to sign Porto centre-back Eder Militao , according to a report .
  • Sephora Drops Olivia Jade’s Collection Amid College Cheating Scandal

    Sephora Drops Olivia Jade’s Collection Amid College Cheating Scandal

    The technology company said that it worked with Loughlin and her daughter in 2017 for a "one time product campaign". When she returned to the US , she was arrested for her alleged involvement in the scandal along with her husband.
    Dolphins emerging to fight Teddy Bridgewater away from Saints

    Dolphins emerging to fight Teddy Bridgewater away from Saints

    Bridgewater was chosen by the Vikings in the 1st round of the 2014 draft and made the Pro Bowl in 2015. Obviously, there's more of an opportunity for Bridgewater to start in Miami than in New Orleans.
    New Chrome extension will hide toxic comments

    New Chrome extension will hide toxic comments

    This new extension will give people "the ability to control for themselves what kind of comments they want to see", said Jigsaw. The Tune icon will show up on the top corner of the Chrome browser when the users visit any of the five websites.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.