Curtis Flowers: Death row conviction quashed over racial bias

Enlarge this image

Enlarge this image

The Supreme Court held on Friday that a black MS death row inmate should get a new trial, saying that the prosecutor who tried him six times for murder engaged in unconstitutional racial discrimination when striking African-American jurors from the panel. "I think they should let him go period", Archie Flowers, Curtis Flowers' brother, told Mississippi's Clarion Ledger.

The Supreme Court decision in Flowers v. MS reverses the conviction of Curtis Flowers, who was convicted of a 1996 quadruple murder at a furniture store.

Now it's up to the state of MS whether to try him for a seventh time.

What happened in the trials?

"The state's relentless, determined effort to rid the jury of black individuals strongly suggests that the state wanted to try Flowers before a jury with as few black jurors as possible, and ideally before an all-white jury". The fourth and fifth trials ended in mistrials.

Flowers was found guilty in four of the six trials - the first three of which were overturned by MS appellate courts due to prosecutorial misconduct.

While prosecutors and defense lawyers are allowed to use what are called peremptory challenges to eliminate potential jurors they are not allowed to do so on the basis of race. He said it broke no new legal ground in dismissing the conviction and death sentence of Curtis Flowers, but reinforced the court's rulings about when a prosecutor's bias eliminated a potential juror.

During that time the state Supreme Court three times threw out his murder conviction for prosecutorial misconduct.

Kavanaugh and Gorsuch have found themselves on opposite sides of several rulings this year, despite Democratic predictions that the pair would harden a conservative bloc on the nation's highest court.

Writing for the majority, Justice Brett Kavanaugh said that prosecutor Doug Evans-who oversaw all six trials-violated Flowers' constitutional rights when he sought to keep African-Americans off of the jury.

Special prosecutor appointed in Smollett probe to investigate dropped charges
Actor Jussie Smollett leaves court after charges against him were dropped by state prosecutors in Chicago, Illinois, U.S. If the office is unwilling to take the case, the request would then go to county prosecutors' offices around the state.

In his decision, Kavanaugh said: "The numbers speak loudly".

Flowers' case is anomalous only because of the number of times he was tried by the same prosecutor and the prosecutor's repeated misconduct.

Lawyers for Flowers had argued before the Supreme Court that district attorney Doug Evans, who prosecuted all six cases and is white, rejected potential black jurors in what amounted to racial discrimination.

What did the dissent say?

He also noted the majority did not dispute the guilty verdict, or the impartiality of the jury - just the prosecutor's conduct.

"Today's decision distorts the record of this case, eviscerates our standard of review, and vacates four murder convictions because the state struck a juror who would have been stricken by any competent attorney", he wrote.

Justice Gorsuch noted that the state of MS is "perfectly free to convict Curtis Flowers again".

The murders occurred on 16 July 1996 in Winona, Mississippi, a small town with a population of around 5,000 that is 53% black and 46% white.

The court did not rule on whether or not he was guilty of murdering Tardy Furniture store owner Bertha Tardy, 59, and three employees, Carmen Rigby, 45, Robert Golden, 42, and Derrick Stewart, 16, in 1996 and instead concentrated on the fact that it was racially prejudiced and against the constitution. Multiple witnesses saw Flowers in the vicinity of the store. Almost $300 was found missing after the killings. He had no criminal record before the conviction. Prosecutors never found a murder weapon or any physical evidence tying him to the scene.

Recommended News

  • Biden Responds To Booker: 'Cory Should Apologize

    Biden Responds To Booker: 'Cory Should Apologize

    Biden's campaign has pushed back fiercely against the barrage of criticism he has received from 2020 presidential candidates. Biden insisted that as a Democratic president, he would bring this style of civility to a bitterly divided Washington.
    Iran Releases Video it Says Shows Shooting Down of US Drone

    Iran Releases Video it Says Shows Shooting Down of US Drone

    He added that the situation is reversible, and said Iran would be willing to meet any constructive steps in turn. Trump previously exited a deal crafted by former President Barack Obama that was not ratified by Congress.
    Trump, Saudi crown prince talk Iran and oil after called-off strike

    Trump, Saudi crown prince talk Iran and oil after called-off strike

    The $8 billion arms sale included precision guided munitions, other bombs and ammunition and aircraft maintenance support. Paul said. "Do I want someone representing me to someone who is selling arms to people who hate our country?"
  • Chromium-based Edge browser now available for Windows 7

    Chromium-based Edge browser now available for Windows 7

    Starting off as a Windows 10 browser and then spreading to macOS, there is now talk of Linux being in Microsoft's sights. Microsoft has yet to reveal a release date for the final version of the new Microsoft Edge Chromium web browser.
    Kamalvandi: Iran not to give Europe more time to save nuclear deal

    Kamalvandi: Iran not to give Europe more time to save nuclear deal

    Standing firm, Rouhani says his nation will be able to withstand the biting US economic sanctions that are crippling its economy. A series of more intrusive United Nations inspections under the deal have verified that Iran has been meeting its commitments.
    Yankees to bring another big bat against Rays

    Yankees to bring another big bat against Rays

    The New York Yankees have officially activated slugger Giancarlo Stanton from the injured list, according to a team announcement. With the acquisition of Encarnacion, Stanton will become New York's starting left fielder in most games.
  • 'Stranger Things' Season 3 Trailer: Get Ready for Netflix's Summer Blockbuster

    'Stranger Things' Season 3 Trailer: Get Ready for Netflix's Summer Blockbuster

    Netflix has released the final trailer for the show's third chapter on Friday morning, and oh boy is there a lot to unpack. According to Netflix , "It's 1985 in Hawkins, Indiana, and summer's heating up".
    Police called to disturbance at UK PM candidate Johnson's home

    Police called to disturbance at UK PM candidate Johnson's home

    The paper said Carrie Symonds could be heard telling Mr Johnson to " get off me" and " get out of my flat". Police said officers found that all occupants were "safe and well" and no offenses had been committed.

    Ozzy will defend rock’s honour as King Thrash in Trolls World Tour

    Kendrick and Timberlake reprise their roles as the eternal optimist Poppy and the curmudgeon Branch in the new musical comedy-adventure from the creators of Shrek .
  • Ali Shamkhani: Iran does not take Trump nor his remarks seriously

    Ali Shamkhani: Iran does not take Trump nor his remarks seriously

    Late Thursday, Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif rejected USA charges that the Global Hawk was in worldwide airspace over the Gulf, and said on Twitter that Iran had retrieved parts of the downed drone in Iranian territorial waters.
    Facebook's Libra Prepared To Counter Privacy Concerns

    Facebook's Libra Prepared To Counter Privacy Concerns

    Some people may be giving Facebook, which this year suffered a corporation-wide 14-hour outage , too much credit. WhatsApp has over 400 million users in India , while Facebook has over 300 million users, according to Statista.

    3 World Series Contenders Nobody is Talking About

    Despite being loaded on offense, the Cardinals have been inefficient in 2019 and rank near the bottom-10 in runs and home runs. Louis has title-winning pedigree and are loaded offensively, but thus far simply haven’t delivered consistent results.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.