Scottish court rules UK PM`s suspension of parliament `unlawful`

Scottish court rules UK PM`s suspension of parliament `unlawful`

Scottish court rules UK PM`s suspension of parliament `unlawful`

The highest civil court in Scotland has ruled Boris Johnson's suspension of Parliament is unlawful, in the latest setback for the UK Prime Minister.

The decision by a three-judge panel on the Court of Session will not immediately force the government to allow lawmakers to reconvene - their suspension officially began on Tuesday, and they're not slated to meet again until October 14.

Parliament was prorogued, or suspended, on Monday until October 14, a move opponents argued was created to thwart their attempts to scrutinize his plans for leaving the European Union and allow him to push through a no-deal Brexit.

Last week, his government lost control of Parliament to an informal coalition of the main opposition and Conservative rebels, who then passed a bill on Monday to block a "no-deal" Brexit within the current deadline.

However, a government source told AFP that "nothing is changing" until the case was concluded.

A lawyer involved in the Scottish case against the government, Jolyon Maugham, tweeted that it would be considered in Britain's Supreme Court starting on Tuesday.

Judge Carloway said: "We are of the opinion that the advice given by the government to her majesty the Queen to prorogue parliament was unlawful and that the prorogation itself was unlawful".

The British government said it was disappointed by the decision and confirmed it would appeal to the Supreme Court. That contradicts the prime minister's stated motive for the move - that his new government needs the time to lay out its agenda in a speech in the middle of next month. "Proroguing Parliament is the legal and necessary way of delivering this", said a statement by 10 Downing Street.

MPs hold protest during Commons prorogation ceremony
They waved banners and tried to stop Mr Bercow leaving his chair to pass through House in a bid to halt proceedings. In all, 293 MPs voted for the prime minister's motion for an early election, far short of the two thirds needed.

Last week, a court in Edinburgh rejected the lawmakers' challenge, saying it was a matter for politicians, not the courts, to decide.

Members of parliament passed legislation last week seeking to force Johnson to ask European Union leaders for an extension if no agreement is reached in hopes of averting what they see as disastrous effects of a so-called no-deal Brexit.

"I think that what I need to do, and what others need to do, is to get back to parliament and open those doors and get back in, and get Boris Johnson back in parliament so we can hold him properly to account".

Scotland's first minister, Scottish National Party (SNP) leader Nicola Sturgeon, echoed his call.

The Supreme Court is to consider United Kingdom ministers' appeal against the ruling.

Legal commentator David Allen Green suggested that the case was likely to fail when it reached the Supreme Court, pointing out that Scottish law was different from that of England and Wales.

He says he is working hard to agree new exit terms, after the deal negotiated by his predecessor Theresa May was rejected by MPs, despite European Union leaders insisting the current terms are the best on offer. Ardent anti-Brexit campaigner Gina Miller was unsuccessful in her attempt to overturn the prorogation of Parliament in an English court last week, but was granted permission to appeal to the UK Supreme Court on September 17.

Recommended News

  • Google Pixel 4 XL to Come with 6.23-inch Display, Snapdragon 855

    Google Pixel 4 XL to Come with 6.23-inch Display, Snapdragon 855

    The first one shows the camera at work, zooming into 8X magnification, although it doesn't seem to be an entirely lossless zoom. The top bezel of the Pixel 4 XL is huge by today's standards, but it does not have a notch so it should make many people happy.
    Apple Asks Developers to Submit iOS 13 Apps for Review

    Apple Asks Developers to Submit iOS 13 Apps for Review

    According to the last minute information, Apple is likely including a new "R1" sensor co-processor in the 2019 series. In addition, we got plenty of details about the Cupertino-based firm new gaming subscription service .
    Cristiano Ronaldo scores four in Portugal win over Lithuania

    Cristiano Ronaldo scores four in Portugal win over Lithuania

    The result keeps Portugal in an automatic qualifying place, five points behind Group B leaders Ukraine. The ball ended up hitting him on the head and went into the goal.
  • Marcelino: Valencia sack manager and replace him with Albert Celades

    Marcelino: Valencia sack manager and replace him with Albert Celades

    Former player Albert Celades, coach of Spain's Under-21 squad until previous year , is expected to replace Marcelino . However, after taking four points from their opening three games, they have taken the decision to replace Marcelino .
    Alabama investigates 5 cases of lung disease tied to vaping

    Alabama investigates 5 cases of lung disease tied to vaping

    The agency said it's providing information from the ongoing federal and state investigation so consumers can protect themselves. The CDC and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) are now in an ongoing investigation to identify a more definitive cause.
    Yelich leads Brewers to win over Cubs

    Yelich leads Brewers to win over Cubs

    Cubs shortstop Javy Baez's MRB revealed a hairline fracture on his left thumb that he suffered last Sunday against the Brewers . That's a devastating blow for a team 2.5 games out of first place and only 2.0 games up in the Wild-Card standings.
  • China keeps penalties on United States  pork, soy, eases some others

    China keeps penalties on United States pork, soy, eases some others

    Punitive duties on soybeans, the biggest USA export to China , and thousands of other items were left unchanged. These products will be exempt from additional tariffs although existing tariffs will not be subject to refunds.
    U.S.  launches massive Google antitrust probe

    U.S. launches massive Google antitrust probe

    A Wall Street Journal report suggested that New York Attorney General Letitia James will lead the investigation into Facebook . An antitrust investigation like this could run parallel with a federal case, causing considerable headaches for Google.
    Stampede during Ashoura ritual leaves dozens dead

    Stampede during Ashoura ritual leaves dozens dead

    The officials spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to give official statements. The incident happened toward the end of the Ashura procession, causing panic and a stampede.
  • EA Kicks Off Free Trials of Cloud Gaming Service for PC Users

    EA Kicks Off Free Trials of Cloud Gaming Service for PC Users

    EA Games emphasizes that the test is more of a technical test rather than a public beta. We've said all along that we want to be where our players are.
    Government will propose banning flavors used in e-cigarettes

    Government will propose banning flavors used in e-cigarettes

    No single device, ingredient or additive has been identified, though many cases involve marijuana vaping devices. Agency officials instead said they were studying if flavors could help smokers quit traditional cigarettes.
    Jamal Adams explains why Jets blew 16-0 lead to Bills

    Jamal Adams explains why Jets blew 16-0 lead to Bills

    The Bills are a fairly young team with 25 players having two or fewer years of experience, including seven rookies. Some of those calls could have been runs to Singletary, but they dialed up passes and the Jets shut them down.

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.