Indu Malhotra | The lone woman judge who dissented on Sabarimala case

Indu Malhotra | The lone woman judge who dissented on Sabarimala case

Indu Malhotra | The lone woman judge who dissented on Sabarimala case

Four judges agreed with the verdict but Justice Indu Malhotra disagreed with the rest of them. Out of the judgements, CJI Dipak Misra wrote one for himself and for Justice Khanwilkar. The board will have to see whether women will be able to enter this pilgrimage season or not.

The court had set up the Constitution bench in October 2017 to consider whether the practice is discriminatory and hence in violation of fundamental rights, or if it qualifies as an "essential religious practice" under Article 25 of the Constitution, which allows the freedom to follow religion in a manner one chooses. "Biological or physiological reasons can not be accepted in freedom for faith", the Chief Justice said.

During the hearings, the Travancore Devaswom Board, which runs the over 800-year-old Lord Ayyappa temple, had told the court that the ban is not anti-women and is voluntarily accepted by them. No physiological and biological factor can be given legitimacy if it doesn't pass the test of conditionality.

Exclusion of women because she menstruates is utterly unconstitutional, said Justice Chandrachud.

He added that: "the right to practice religion is available to both men and women".

In a dissenting judgement, Justice Indu Malhotra said that it was not for courts to decide which religious practices are to be struck down except in cases of social evils like Sati.

"The Deity's concept was not taken into consideration", said Rahul Easwar, president of the Ayyappa Dharma Sena (Ayyappa Religious Army), that claims to protect the interests of the Lord Ayyappa. We will certainly file a review petition.

Canada MPs, in symbolic move, vote to strip Suu Kyi of citizenship
Thursday's decision marks the first time the Rights Council has itself opted to create such a mechanism. Myanmar has denied the claims, saying that it was fighting back against militants.

"The right of an individual to worship a specific manifestation of the deity, in accordance with the tenets of that faith or shrine, is protected by Article 25 (1) of the Constitution".

The matter, which witnessed shifting stands of the Kerala government with the change of governments, saw the Left Front government telling the court that Lord Jagannath's temple, Kash Vishwnath temple and similar religious places are not denominational temples but the Ramakrishna Mission was a denominational entity. This is placing the burden of a men's celibacy on women.

The top court heard the PIL filed by the non-profit body Indian Lawyers Association which sought the entry of all women and girls to the temple dedicated to Lord Ayyappan and challenged Rule 3 (b) of the Kerala Hindu Places of Public Worship Rules 1965.

India's Supreme Court in New Delhi, where a string of verdicts in recent weeks have granted more rights to women, gay couples and religious minorities as he prepares to retire from the bench next month.

The higher bench had reserved its judgment in the case on August 2. The Bench refused to maintain the Status-Quo on this issue citing Religious feelings.

The Supreme Court has said that devotion can not be subjected to gender discrimination. It also stigmatises women as "lesser beings".

Recommended News

  • Is No Credit Better Than Having Bad Credit?

    In fact, that’s the best possible use of credit — engaging it to do something that can help you make money. No Credit The good news about having no credit history is there’s nothing negative about you out there.

    The US Open Final: Who Will Make it?

    The 34-year-old Swiss won the first two sets 6-4 and 7-5, forcing an injured and struggling Djokovic to retire in the third. If she’s at her best, then she’ll make it to the final and if she performs on the day the title will be hers.
    Arsenal to use Aaron Ramsey money on Sevilla ace Ever Banega?

    Arsenal to use Aaron Ramsey money on Sevilla ace Ever Banega?

    It had looked likely the north London club would eventually agree a new deal with the Wales global with a four-year extension in the pipeline.
  • CC Sabathia gets ejected on goal  pitch, loses bonus

    CC Sabathia gets ejected on goal pitch, loses bonus

    Sabathia needed to complete seven innings Thursday to earn a $500,000 contract bonus by reaching 155 innings this season. NY went on to score four runs in the inning, including home runs by Luke Voit and Giancarlo Stanton.
    New research finds Mediterranean diet reduces risk of depression

    New research finds Mediterranean diet reduces risk of depression

    "Also, the link to inflammation as a plausible mechanism to explain a link between diet and mental health is highly tenuous".
    Ontario government to introduce legislation today regulating recreational pot

    Ontario government to introduce legislation today regulating recreational pot

    The legislation further allows cannabis to be smoked by those over 19 wherever the smoking of tobacco is permitted. The private retail store model, however will only be in place by April 2019.
  • How Healthcare Providers Can Reduce Insurance Claim Denials

    And, it’s important to account for the time and effort spent by administrative staff handling these denied claims. They also have the potential to adversely affect patients’ opinions about the organization.
    Cleveland Cavaliers remain interested in Minnesota Timberwolves G Jimmy Butler

    Cleveland Cavaliers remain interested in Minnesota Timberwolves G Jimmy Butler

    A trade to Miami would reunite Butler with Dwyane Wade, with whom he was teammates and close friends with for one year in Chicago. Teams believe Thibodeau is making counterproposals that he knows franchises will never accept, according to the report .
    More A-Shares Inclusion Could Lift This China ETF

    More A-Shares Inclusion Could Lift This China ETF

    Poland has officially achieved Developed market status and Iceland is being reclassified to Frontier market status. FTSE did not give a forecast of how much inflows will come from active investors benchmarked against the index.
  • Christine Blasey Ford steps into spotlight to detail assault allegations

    Christine Blasey Ford steps into spotlight to detail assault allegations

    Manchin was among a handful of Democrats from red and purple states that Kavanaugh supporters were targeting as possible votes. He also took issue with the notion of waiting for an FBI investigation into the allegations against Kavanaugh.
    Tanushree Dutta-Nana Patekar controversy: Twinkle Khanna backs Tanushree, details inside

    Tanushree Dutta-Nana Patekar controversy: Twinkle Khanna backs Tanushree, details inside

    But amidst all the controversy, journalist Janice Sequeira also made some revelations and they are shocking, to say the least. Aamir said it would not be right for him to comment, but "whenever something like this does happen it is really a sad thing".
    David Beckham successfully gets speeding charge thrown out of court

    David Beckham successfully gets speeding charge thrown out of court

    His clients have in the past included cricketer Andrew Flintoff, explorer Sir Ranulph Fiennes and golfer Colin Montgomerie. "It also appears to show speeding is not seen as risky by courts".

We are pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news.
Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper.
Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.